Pick a Bagel Cafe & Catering

785 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10065 Order now

Serving Breakfast and More!


Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

Pick a Bagel Cafe & Catering Reviews on Grubhub


Top Reviewer
The food was sooooo good !! Hands down the best bagel ever plus the vegetable cream cheese was EVERYTHING ! Best of all the shipping minimum is only $6 !!!!!! I say yes please !


Top Reviewer
Excellent, despite snow storm made it early. I'm so sorry to even ask you to deliver in snow but I hurt my foot and couldn't walk to your store


Top Reviewer
By far my most favorite place!!! Not just bagels but their lunch meat sandwiches are delicious!!! You won't be disappointed.


Top Reviewer
Great service. Always get deliveries before the expected delivery time.


Top Reviewer
They slathered my muffin in butter and jelly it was amazing!!!!

Reviews from Seamless.com

Pick a Bagel Cafe & Catering Reviews on Seamless


1 review
Awesome bagels. Best bagels I've had since I've moved here. Bacon egg and cheese breakfast sandwich was off the hook. And my wife had a great white fish bagel sandwich. Highly recommended.
Great service too. People on the phone were super nice. They forgot my OJ, but called the store and the manager Marom hooked me up. Got another OJ within 5 minutes and he gave me a free brownie. Def ordering again soon.


Top Reviewer
Food was great and they even called to tell me they were out of the muffin I wanted and asked what other kind of muffin I wanted. Very friendly and delivery was early.

Justin G

Top Reviewer
Bagel freshly baked, entire order newly cooked as requested, a very good alternative to other local restaurants for breakfast sandwiches.


Top Reviewer
I order the same thing every time. Bagel and coffee. It's always delicious and arrives promptly. Thank you.


Top Reviewer
The bagels are good and the bacon, egg & cheese sandwiches are the best. Always on time. Always good.

About us

Bagels, Bakery, Breakfast, Coffee and Tea, Deli, Dinner, Healthy, Lunch Specials, Salads, Sandwiches, Smoothies and Juices, Soup, Vegetarian, Wraps

Pick A Bagel offers delicious dining, takeout and delivery to New York, ny. Pick A Bagel is a cornerstone in the New York community and has been recognized for its outstanding American cuisine, excellent service and friendly staff. Our American restaurant is known for its modern interpretation of classic dishes and its insistence on only using high quality fresh ingredients.